The email arrives a few weeks after you submitted. Thank you for your tender. On this occasion you have not been successful. Attached is a document most suppliers open, scroll to the scores, sigh at, and close.
That document is the most useful thing a public buyer will ever send you. It is the only time someone who has read your bid closely writes down, in detail, exactly where it fell short — and, under the Procurement Act 2023, exactly why the winner did better.
What you are entitled to
Before a contracting authority can enter into a contract awarded through a competitive procedure, it has to give every supplier that submitted an assessed tender an assessment summary. That is a legal requirement under the Act, not a courtesy.
The summary covers your tender and the most advantageous tender — the one that won. For each award criterion you should see how your tender was assessed and how the winner's was, with reasons. Under the old regulations the equivalent letter was often a table of scores and a paragraph of generalities. Buyers now have to explain themselves.
Then comes the standstill period: eight working days from the publication of the contract award notice, during which the contract cannot be signed. That window is what makes a challenge possible at all. Once a contract has been entered into, the options narrow sharply.
How to read the summary properly
Read it twice. Once for the sting, once for the information.
Start with the gaps, not the totals. A loss by four points overall is usually a loss by twelve points on one question and a few small wins elsewhere. Find the one or two questions where the gap to the winner was widest. That is where the work is.
Read the evaluator's words against your own answer. Put your submitted response next to the comment. "Did not demonstrate how mobilisation risks would be managed" usually means exactly that: you described the plan but not what would happen if it slipped. The comment tells you what the scoring guidance rewarded.
Look at what the winner was praised for. You will not see their bid, but you will see why it scored. "Named key personnel with relevant contract experience", "specific, measurable social value commitments", "a clear escalation route" — those phrases are the shape of a top-band answer in that buyer's eyes.
Check price separately. If you lost on price, the summary will show it. Losing narrowly on quality and heavily on price is a different problem from the reverse, and the fix is not more writing.
When a challenge is worth considering
Most losses are not worth challenging, and a supplier who challenges every loss gets a reputation quickly. But some are, and the window is short.
Signs something may have genuinely gone wrong:
- The scores do not match the published scoring methodology — for example, a response meeting every requirement was given a mid-band mark with no reason.
- The buyer appears to have used a criterion or weighting that was never published.
- The comments on your bid describe something you did not write, or miss something you plainly did.
- The arithmetic does not add up.
Under the Act, if proceedings are started and the authority is notified during the standstill period, the authority is automatically prevented from entering into the contract until the court decides otherwise. After standstill, that automatic suspension is not available. And proceedings generally have to be brought within 30 days of the day the supplier knew, or ought to have known, about the problem.
The practical first step is almost never a court. It is a clear, polite clarification question to the buyer inside the standstill period, asking how a specific score was reached against the published criteria. Many apparent errors are explained in a reply; some are corrected. If it is genuinely serious, talk to a procurement lawyer that week, not the week after.
Turning the loss into the next bid
The real value of an assessment summary is not this contract. It is the next six.
- Keep every summary in one place. After three or four losses, patterns show up that no single letter reveals — the same question type always scoring low, the same weakness in mobilisation, social value answers that are always "generic".
- Rewrite the weakest answer now, while the comment is fresh. Store the improved version in your answer library. The next buyer will ask nearly the same question.
- Fix evidence gaps, not just wording. If you keep losing marks for lack of a relevant case study, the answer is to win a smaller contract that gives you one, not to write a better paragraph about the absence.
- Ask for a call if the buyer offers one. Many will talk you through the summary. Listen more than you argue.
- Watch for the same buyer again. Contracts are re-let. If you lost a three-year contract today, the same requirement is likely to appear again in two to three years — and you now know exactly what that buyer values.
The loss you learn nothing from
The expensive loss is not the one where you came second. It is the one where you never read the summary and submitted the same weak answer to the next six buyers.
TendersHub's bid pipeline lets you record each bid from found to won or lost, with the submitted date and the value, so the losses sit next to the wins and the patterns are visible. And when the next opportunity from that buyer appears, keyword alerts will bring it to your inbox the morning it is published, among 11,100+ live UK tenders.
Browse live tenders or see your best matches free on /match.
